MELI Local Currency Says the Business Grew 50% - The Dollar Says It Grew 12%. Which One Is Real?

The Widest Currency Gap This Coverage Has Ever Measured

MercadoLibre's Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31, 2014 reports net revenue of $115.4 million, up just 12.3% year-over-year from $102.7 million - the slowest reported quarterly growth rate this coverage has measured, well below every quarter of 2013 (22.7%-26.5%) and even below 2012's low point of 19.2% in Q3. Read in isolation, that looks like the first real sign of a genuine slowdown after seven straight quarters of 19%-plus growth. It isn't. The Company's own disclosure shows net revenue grew 49.9% in local currency for the same quarter - meaning the gap between what the underlying business did and what shows up in dollars widened to 37.5 percentage points, more than double Q2 2012's previous record 19-point gap. Two currency events explain nearly all of it: the Argentine peso devalued roughly 23% in January 2014 (from 6.52 to about 8.0 pesos per dollar), and Venezuela shifted the exchange rate used to re-measure its operations from the official 6.3 BsF-per-dollar rate to the SICAD 1 rate of 10.7 BsF per dollar - both currencies this coverage flagged as pending threats in last quarter's subsequent-events footnote.

The clearest confirmation that this is a currency story, not a demand story, sits in the operational metrics rather than the income statement. Gross merchandise volume^» (GMV) grew 15.0% to $1,797.3 million, while items sold grew faster, 19.9% to 21.7 million - the first quarter in this coverage where items-sold growth has outpaced GMV growth, reversing a currency-inflation pattern that has run the other direction (GMV growing faster than items, as devaluation lifted per-item dollar prices) in every quarter tracked through 2013. The take rate^» (net revenues over GMV) slipped to 6.42% from 6.57%, a fourth straight period of decline. None of this says MercadoLibre sold fewer things or attracted fewer buyers - registered users grew 21.0% to 103.7 million, total payment volume^» (TPV) grew 24.8% to $664.0 million, and total payment transactions grew 37.3% to 9.2 million, all comfortably ahead of the reported revenue line. It says the average dollar value of each transaction fell, because two of the five currencies MercadoLibre operates in just got materially cheaper against the dollar in the same three months.

The Prescription

MercadoLibre should start disclosing a local-currency revenue figure and the currency-translation bridge in its own earnings materials every quarter it operates in Argentina and Venezuela, not bury the 49.9%-versus-12.3% gap two sections deep in the MD&A's local-currency growth table. A 37.5-point gap between the two readings is now large enough that a reader relying on the headline dollar number alone would badly misjudge whether the underlying business is decelerating - and the gap is only going to keep widening as Venezuela's multi-tier exchange system (official, SICAD 1, SICAD 2, all reporting simultaneously at 6.3, 10.7, and 49.81 BsF per dollar respectively as of quarter-end) diverges further from reality. A dedicated local-currency reconciliation, presented as prominently as the headline growth number, would let a reader tell the difference between "the business slowed" and "the currency moved" without needing to reconstruct it from a footnote, the way this analysis just had to.

What it should stop doing: continuing to treat Venezuela's SICAD 1 rate as the operative re-measurement rate for financial reporting while SICAD 2 - the rate the government itself opened to "all industry sectors" on March 24, 2014 - already trades at more than 4.5 times SICAD 1's level (49.81 versus 10.7 BsF per dollar). The Company's own sensitivity disclosure (see Beyond the Usual below) shows what happens if that gap collapses: Venezuela's reported net revenue would fall from $19.4 million to $3.8 million, an 80% haircut, on the same underlying transactions. Continuing to report at SICAD 1 while SICAD 2 is the rate increasingly available to "all industry sectors" risks a single-quarter restatement shock the size of an entire segment, whenever the Company (or its auditors) eventually concludes SICAD 1 is no longer the right rate to use.

Key Financial Metrics

Three months ended March 31, 2014 vs. three months ended March 31, 2013 - consolidated, reported in USD (MercadoLibre reports natively in dollars; no FX conversion is needed)

Metric	Q1 2014	Q1 2013	YoY
Net revenues	$115.4M	$102.7M	⚠️ +12.3% reported (✅ +49.9% at local currency - see above)
Cost of net revenues	$(31.5)M	$(28.6)M	⚠️ +10.1%
Gross profit (72.66% margin)	$83.8M	$74.1M (72.11% margin)	✅ +13.2%, margin +0.55pp
Income from operations» (29.46% margin)	$34.0M	$28.6M (27.81% margin)	✅ +19.0%, margin +1.65pp
Adjusted EBITDA	not disclosed	not disclosed	⚠️ still undisclosed, every filing this coverage has tracked
Blended tax rate	22.4%	30.9%	✅ -8.5pp - last year's non-deductible Venezuela devaluation loss inflated the base
Effective tax rate	39.3%	29.6%	🔴 +9.7pp - Argentina's tax holiday eroding ahead of its September 2014 expiration
Net income» (attributable to MELI)	$30.3M	$17.5M	⚠️ +73.1% - mostly a currency-timing artifact, not operating strength (see below)
Adjusted net income (non-GAAP, excludes Venezuela FX)	$27.7M	$23.4M	✅ +18.4% - the more honest read on core growth
Diluted EPS	$0.69	$0.40	⚠️ +72.5%, same FX caveat as net income
Operating cash flow	$27.6M	$30.1M	⚠️ -8.2%
Free cash flow» (Company's own reconciliation)	$20.5M	$24.0M	⚠️ -14.6% - a second straight quarterly decline, though nowhere near FY2013's 76.8% full-year collapse
Capital expenditures	$7.1M	$6.7M	⚠️ +6.0% - a return to a normal run-rate after FY2013's real-estate spree
Cash, ST & LT investments (period end)	$263.5M	$262.6M (Dec. 31, 2013)	✅ +0.4pp
Loans payable and other financial liabilities (period end)	$9.5M	$15.9M (Dec. 31, 2013)	✅ -40.2% - Venezuelan and Argentine bank lines amortizing down

Net income attributable to MELI's 73.1% jump looks like the standout number this quarter, but it is overwhelmingly a comparison-quarter artifact: Q1 2013 absorbed a $6.4 million non-deductible foreign-currency loss from Venezuela's February 2013 devaluation, while Q1 2014 booked a $2.7 million devaluation gain instead, as the Argentine peso's January devaluation produced a $4.6 million currency gain that more than offset Venezuela's ongoing re-measurement losses. Strip both quarters' Venezuela FX effects out - which the Company does itself, in a non-GAAP "Adjusted Net Income" reconciliation it has disclosed every quarter since Q1 2013 - and the growth rate falls to a still-solid but far less dramatic 18.4%, roughly tracking the pace of the underlying business rather than the year-over-year currency swing.

Net income more than doubling headline growth from FX timing, while effective tax rate jumps almost 10 points from the same country's tax holiday eroding, are two sides of the same Argentina/Venezuela currency story running through this quarter's entire income statement.

Key Operational Metrics

Three months ended March 31, 2014 vs. three months ended March 31, 2013

Metric	Q1 2014	Q1 2013	YoY
Gross merchandise volume» (GMV)	$1,797.3M	$1,563.3M	⚠️ +15.0% - the first quarter items-sold growth has outpaced GMV growth in this coverage
Total payment volume» (TPV)	$664.0M	$532.1M	✅ +24.8%
Total payment transactions	9.2M	6.7M	✅ +37.3%
Confirmed registered users (cumulative, period end)	103.7M	85.7M	✅ +21.0%
New confirmed registered users (in period)	4.3M	4.2M	⚠️ +2.4% - a sharp deceleration from the ~15-18% new-user growth this coverage has tracked in recent years
Items sold	21.7M	18.1M	✅ +19.9%
Take rate» (net revenues / GMV)	6.42%	6.57%	⚠️ -0.15pp - a fourth straight period of decline
TPV as % of GMV (ex. motors/real estate)	36.9%	34.0%	✅ +2.9pp - MercadoPago penetration keeps climbing
Capital expenditures	$7.1M	$6.7M	⚠️ +6.0%

New registered-user growth of just 2.4% is the softest reading this coverage has measured for that metric, even as cumulative registered users and every payment-volume metric kept accelerating - worth watching next quarter to see whether it is genuinely a growth-deceleration signal or another artifact of the same currency-driven softness depressing this quarter's other dollar-denominated numbers.

Five Country Segments - Brazil and Venezuela Both Improved Sharply; Argentina, Mexico, and Other Countries All Fell

MercadoLibre reports the same five geographic segments adopted in Q3 2010 - Brazil, Argentina, Mexico, Venezuela, and Other Countries.

Segment	Q1 2014 Revenue	YoY Revenue	Direct contribution margin, Q1 2014	Direct contribution margin, Q1 2013	Margin change
Brazil	$52.4M	✅ +9.8%	41.8%	35.1%	✅ +6.7pp
Argentina	$28.0M	✅ +8.9%	39.5%	47.4%	🔴 -7.9pp
Mexico	$8.1M	⚠️ +3.8%	43.4%	47.2%	⚠️ -3.8pp
Venezuela	$19.4M	✅ +27.9%	70.9%	60.3%	✅ +10.6pp
Other Countries	$7.5M	✅ +17.6%	48.1%	55.3%	⚠️ -7.2pp
Total	$115.4M	⚠️ +12.3%	46.6%	44.1%	✅ +2.5pp

Brazil's direct contribution margin swing (+6.7pp) is its best single-quarter reading in this coverage's recent history, driven by a 9.7% decrease in general and administrative expenses and a 9.7% decrease in sales and marketing costs even as cost of net revenues rose 10.0% on higher collection fees - genuine operating leverage, not a currency effect, since Brazil's real depreciated far less than Argentina's peso or Venezuela's bolivar this quarter. Venezuela's margin gain (+10.6pp, to a portfolio-best 70.9%) looks like a currency-timing benefit rather than an operating one: Venezuela's functional currency is the U.S. dollar for reporting purposes, so its revenue and direct costs both move with the re-measurement rate rather than local business trends, and the segment's own sensitivity disclosure (see Beyond the Usual below) shows how fragile that reading is to which Venezuelan exchange rate ultimately applies. Argentina's continued deterioration (-7.9pp, extending a decline that has now run for six of the last seven quarters this coverage has tracked) includes a new $2.4 million write-off of tax credits tied to the software-development law transition discussed in Beyond the Usual - a one-time cost, not a structural one, but it accounts for a meaningful share of this quarter's segment-level damage. Mexico (-3.8pp) and Other Countries (-7.2pp) both weakened for reasons the filing attributes mainly to higher collection fees and bad-debt charges as MercadoPago penetration rises in those markets too - the same payment-driven cost dynamic Brazil has been absorbing for several years.

Beyond the Usual

The São Paulo tax claim moved further into Brazil's judicial courts, with both sides now formally engaged - still "remote," still zero reserve

The $18.1 million São Paulo municipal tax claim (grown from $17.5 million at year-end via accrued interest and the exchange rate) that lost every administrative appeal and moved to the 9th Treasury Court of the City of São Paulo last quarter advanced further this quarter: the São Paulo Municipal Council was formally summoned on January 28, 2014, and on April 8, 2014 - a subsequent event, three weeks before this 10-Q was signed - the Municipal Council presented its defense. MercadoLibre now must respond to that defense. This is the first quarter since the lawsuit was filed that both sides have actually exchanged substantive filings in the judicial proceeding, rather than the case simply sitting on a docket.

Genuine adversarial litigation is now underway - the tax authority has formally responded to MercadoLibre's lawsuit, not merely been served with it - on a claim large enough that the Company has already deposited $18.1 million in a Brazilian court to pursue it. Despite this active escalation, the filing's language is unchanged from every prior quarter this coverage has tracked: management and legal counsel still call the risk of loss "remote," with zero reserve. A claim that both sides are now actively litigating in court, with real cash already committed, calling its own loss risk "remote" is the same disconnect this coverage has flagged for three consecutive filings - now with the Municipal Council's own defense on the record to evaluate, rather than an unanswered lawsuit.

Argentina's effective tax rate jumped almost 10 points as its software-development tax holiday nears its scheduled expiration - and a new decree still leaves qualification for 2015-2019 unresolved

Argentina's consolidated effective tax rate rose to 39.3% this quarter, up 9.7 percentage points from 29.6% a year earlier - a jump the filing attributes primarily to the software-development tax holiday (last quarter's post flagged as the source of Argentina's unusually low 17.7% FY2013 effective rate) beginning to erode ahead of its scheduled September 2014 expiration. The Company now expects an average 2014 tax rate of approximately 22%, since it anticipates no income tax holiday benefit at all during the fourth quarter of 2014. The regulatory decree needed to qualify for the new software-development law (which would extend reduced-but-still-material relief through 2019) was finally issued by Argentina's Industry Secretary in late February 2014 - after the fiscal year closed and roughly two and a half months before this 10-Q was signed - but the Company states only that it is "currently analyzing" the decree's compliance requirements (annual incremental export and R&D-spending ratios), with no indication yet of whether it expects to qualify.

This is the tax-holiday-expiration risk this coverage has tracked since it first surfaced in the FY2013 10-K now showing up in the actual numbers, not just the disclosure: a nearly 10-point effective-tax-rate jump in a single quarter, in a segment worth 24.2% of consolidated revenue. The 22% average rate MercadoLibre now guides to for full-year 2014 is still well below Argentina's statutory rate, but it's a meaningfully worse outcome than FY2013's 17.7% - and whether the Company ultimately qualifies for the new law's reduced relief through 2019, or loses the benefit altogether for some stretch of 2014-2015, remains genuinely unresolved as of this filing. Worth checking explicitly again next quarter.

A new state-prosecutor claim in southern Brazil could require MercadoLibre to actively police its own marketplace for unlawful listings

A state prosecutor in Porto Alegre, State of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, filed a claim against MercadoLibre's Brazilian subsidiary on November 20, 2013, alleging the Company should be held liable for any offer or sale of unlawful products or services through its website. A preliminary injunction granted November 25, 2013 already orders the subsidiary to monitor and prevent such listings; the subsidiary was formally summoned January 22, 2014, presented its defense March 11, 2014, and won a temporary stay of the injunction on March 26, 2014 pending an interlocutory appeal that remained unresolved as of the filing date.

This is a new legal theory beyond the intellectual-property and consumer-fraud claims this coverage has tracked for years: a state prosecutor, not a private plaintiff, seeking to hold the Company to an affirmative monitoring obligation for its entire marketplace rather than a "notice and take down" standard (the standard Brazil's own Superior Court of Justice affirmed in the long-running Citizen Watch trademark case, also still active this quarter). Management calls the risk of losing "reasonably possible, but not probable" - the same middle-tier language used for the Citizen dispute - but a prosecutorial monitoring mandate, if it survives appeal, would be a meaningfully different compliance burden than a per-claim takedown obligation.

Venezuela's segment note includes a sensitivity disclosure this coverage hasn't seen before: MercadoLibre modeled what Q1 2014's Venezuelan segment results would have looked like at a hypothetical 50 BsF-per-dollar exchange rate - deliberately close to the actual SICAD 2 rate of 49.81 BsF per dollar that began operating March 24, 2014. Under that scenario, Venezuela's actual $19.4 million of net revenue would instead have been $3.8 million, and direct contribution would have fallen from $13.7 million to $2.0 million - an 80% haircut to the segment on the same underlying transactions, purely from which government-sanctioned exchange rate applies. The Company frames this explicitly as a scenario, not a forecast, but it quantifies just how much of Venezuela's reported 16.8%-of-revenue, 70.9%-margin segment is currently an artifact of which of three simultaneously-quoted Venezuelan exchange rates (official 6.3, SICAD 1 10.7, SICAD 2 49.81 BsF per dollar) the Company continues to use for re-measurement.

On April 8, 2014 - a subsequent event - MercadoLibre paid $33.6 million in cash to acquire three companies operating online real-estate classifieds platforms in Chile (portalinmobiliario.com) and Mexico (guiadeinmuebles.com), with up to $5 million more in earnouts contingent on 2014-2015 revenue targets. This is a genuine expansion of the classifieds vertical the Company has run in U.S. real estate since earlier years, extending it into two more Latin American markets via acquisition rather than organic build-out - a strategic signal the headline financial metrics this quarter don't otherwise convey.

The Board approved the 2014 Long Term Retention Plan on March 31, 2014 - the last day of the quarter - adding a seventh overlapping stock-price-linked compensation tranche (2009 through 2014) with an expected total cost of $12.8 million, referencing 2013's $118.48 average closing stock price as its variable-payment baseline. In a genuine first for this coverage, the four oldest tranches (2009-2012) posted negative compensation expense this quarter - a net $0.6 million combined credit - because MercadoLibre's own stock price fell during the period, mechanically reducing the accrued liability on those variable-payment plans. The mechanism this coverage has tracked driving G&A costs higher in nearly every 2013 filing worked in reverse this quarter, for the first time.

Two dividend increases were confirmed as subsequent events: the board approved a $7.3 million ($0.166/share) quarterly dividend on February 27, 2014 (paid April 15) and a second, identical $7.3 million dividend on April 30, 2014 (payable July 15) - both roughly 16% larger per-share than the $6.3 million ($0.143/share) dividend paid January 15, 2014 for Q4 2013.

As of March 31, 2014, 92.2% of MercadoLibre's consolidated cash and investments sit in foreign subsidiaries, and 52.9% of the consolidated total is held outside the United States entirely, mostly in Brazil, Argentina, and Venezuela - the same three currency-controlled or currency-volatile jurisdictions discussed throughout this filing. The Company states plainly it intends to reinvest undistributed foreign earnings locally rather than repatriate them, which limits the practical relevance of the headline $263.5 million cash-and-investments figure as a measure of dollars actually available to fund U.S.-dollar obligations.

No off-balance-sheet arrangements, unconsolidated joint ventures, or variable interest entities were disclosed this quarter - consistent with every prior filing this coverage has tracked. The litigation reserve for probable losses rose modestly to $3.52 million (from FY2013's $3.3 million) and reasonably-possible exposure rose to $4.06 million (from FY2013's $4.02 million), alongside Brazilian ordinary-court case counts rising to 636 (from 624) and consumer-court cases to 3,191 (from 3,149) - continuing the slow, steady climb this coverage has tracked in nearly every recent quarter.

Coverage Table

Theme	Q1 2014	Q1 2013	YoY	Why it matters
Net revenue, reported (USD)	$115.4M	$102.7M	⚠️ +12.3%	Slowest reported growth this coverage has measured
Net revenue, local currency	n/a	n/a	✅ +49.9%	37.5pp gap vs. reported growth - more than double the prior record (19pp, Q2 2012)
GMV vs. items sold	+15.0% vs. +19.9%	n/a	⚠️ -4.9pp gap	First quarter items-sold growth has outpaced GMV growth in this coverage
Net income attributable to MELI	$30.3M	$17.5M	⚠️ +73.1%	Mostly a currency-timing artifact vs. last year's Venezuela devaluation loss
Adjusted net income (ex-FX)	$27.7M	$23.4M	✅ +18.4%	The more honest read on underlying growth
Effective tax rate	39.3%	29.6%	🔴 +9.7pp	Argentina's tax holiday eroding ahead of its September 2014 expiration
São Paulo tax claim	Municipal Council presented its defense April 8, 2014; still "remote," zero reserve	n/a	🔴	Active judicial litigation now underway, both sides engaged

Target Valuation Range

DCF fair-value range: roughly $1,869 million (base case) to $4,257 million (bull case) in enterprise value - against the current $3,945.5 million enterprise value, the base case now covers about 47% (a real improvement from Q4 2013's ~39%, though driven mostly by the lower price rather than a stronger cash-flow outlook), and the bull case clears actual enterprise value for the first time in several quarters at ~108%. The reverse DCF implies the market is demanding roughly 12.4% perpetual growth - essentially unchanged from Q4's ~12.3%, continuing the multi-quarter climb in the growth rate this coverage has tracked even as the stock itself keeps falling.

Market cap fell to $4,199.5 million as the stock declined to $95.11, down 11.8% from Q4 2013's ~$4,759.3 million (MercadoLibre has never split its common stock since its August 2007 IPO, so no split adjustment applies).

Market cap → enterprise value	Q1 2014
Share price (period-end, Mar 31 2014)	$95.11
Shares outstanding	44,153,892
Market capitalization	$4,199.5 million
Total liabilities (loans payable)	$9.5 million
Less: cash and equivalents	$263.5 million
Enterprise value	$3,945.5 million

Peer-multiple sanity check	Q4 2013 (TTM/FY)	Q1 2014 (TTM)	Change
Net revenue	$472.6 million	~$485.3 million	-
Net income (attrib. to MELI)	$117.5 million	~$130.3 million	-
Free cash flow	$28.3 million	~$21.7 million	-
EV/Sales	9.55x	8.1x	down
P/E	~40.5x	32.2x	down
EV/FCF	159.5x	~182x	up

EV/FCF is still elevated versus a "normal" MercadoLibre quarter, though the trailing base is no longer being dragged down by an active real-estate-purchase spree the way it was a year ago.

Scenario	Key assumption	Implied EV	% of current EV
Current (period-end close)	Actual Mar 31, 2014 close	$3,945.5 million	100%
Base	Revenue growth 22%→10% over 5 years; FCF margin 15%→22% (reflecting return to $7.1M normal capex run-rate); 13% discount, 4% terminal growth	$1,869 million	47% (up from Q4 2013's ~39%)
Bull	Revenue growth 26%→11% over 5 years; FCF margin 20%→30%; 11% discount, 5% terminal growth	$4,257 million	108% (clears EV for the first time since Q1 2012)

The base case's improvement is largely because the lower stock price pulled the EV base down faster than the DCF's own fair-value estimate moved. The bull case still requires assuming both faster growth and a materially higher FCF margin than the Company has delivered in any recent quarter.

Reverse DCF: holding the 13% discount rate and solving for the perpetual FCF growth rate that would justify today's $3,945.5 million enterprise value on the $21.7 million trailing FCF base gives roughly 12.4% growth, forever - essentially flat with Q4 2013's ~12.3%, continuing the multi-quarter climb in the growth rate this coverage has tracked, even though the stock itself fell again this quarter.

Whether the currency-driven reported-growth slowdown flagged above persists or reverses once Argentina and Venezuela's currencies stabilize is the single biggest swing factor for next quarter's read on this valuation - a genuine local-currency deceleration would be a much worse signal than the currency-mechanics story this quarter's numbers actually tell.

---